Brad Delong asks
Macro Advisors projects 3.1% real GDP growth over the next four quarters, then rising to 4.0% real GDP growth for the second half of 2012.
It could happen. But where is the demand supposed to come from?
I haven’t seen the internals of the Macro Advisors model but these numbers don’t sound off to me as a baseline. How would they come about.
1) Rapid increase in multi-family housing built to rent. If rents continue to rise then profits on new multifamily structure will be high. Tight credit for young borrowers combined with high gas prices will also push large rental complex demand.
Here I actually have some fear as to whether the North East corridor will be friendly enough to new development to allow this to proceed at its maximum pace. However, the sun-belt is still very open to bulldoze-and-build. Not to mention it is currently heavily car dependent, so I could see some rapid changes beginning to take place.
2) An end to fiscal contraction. The contraction in State and Local spending has been an intense blow to both employment and GDP. However, this should be coming to an end. I do not expect a government hiring boom anytime soon. However, we don’t need a boom. What we need is for State and Local to simply stop contracting.
3) Net Exports. This is a hard call with all that is going on in Europe but both inflation and growth in the developing world should be slowing US import growth and increasing US export growth.
4) Believe it or not, consumer spending. Consumer spending has not been a superstar but until the last quarter it was decent enough. Gas prices are the biggest variable here, but again I do not see the fundamentals supporting oil over $100 a barrel right now. I haven’t had a chance to read the latest thinking on the energy markets, but to me there looks to be too much supply in the wings to get oil this high.
Unlike 2008 there is much less incentive to “ground speculate.” That is slow pumping in the hopes that future prices will be ever higher. This is because we see a lot of potential energy supply coming online and we see a US market that seems to be moving rapidly towards conservation and is unexpectedly sensitive to price.
5) Continued heavy investment in Equipment and Software by businesses. The current strength in E&P is hard to explain and its easy to see it going away. However, if you just assume that something that we don’t fully understand is boosting investment and look at it from a business cycle perspective then a strengthening economy should lead to even more rapid E&P accumulation.
Now, of course predictions are hard – especially about the future. The wave of forecast downgrades may continue. However, gloom is not a model. You have to base your best guess on your best understanding of the underlying economy. To me that points to growth, even if we have seen a string of disappointments over the last nine months.

4 comments
Comments feed for this article
Saturday ~ July 30th, 2011 at 9:43 pm
foosion
>>An end to fiscal contraction>>
The Feds are discussing massive fiscal contraction as part of the debt ceiling discussions. We’ll need new appropriations by Oct 1 and odds are good GOP will go for further cuts.
That could well be enough to offset everything you mention.
Sunday ~ July 31st, 2011 at 7:28 am
Sunday links: default distraction | Abnormal Returns
[...] How to get to a more positive economy in 2012. (Modeled Behavior) [...]
Sunday ~ July 31st, 2011 at 11:14 am
Andy Harless
The problem here is that almost all the risks to your forecast are on the downside. This might be a reasonable modal forecast — the single most likely outcome — but I’m not sure it’s even a median, let alone a mean. Given the apparently skewed distribution of possible outcomes, an unbiased mean forecast would be much more pessimistic.
Monday ~ August 1st, 2011 at 1:32 pm
Friedman's Ghost
Economists did not (do not) see this coming. They never do. Economists in general cannot see a slowdown coming no matter how obvious the slowdown is. Quite frankly, this slowdown is getting obvious (see ISM for example).
Moreover, given budget constraints in the US including cutbacks at city and state levels, given Europe will soon be in recession in conjunction with various austerity measures (assuming Europe is not in recession already), given the impending slowdown in China, Canadian GDP negative and an outright economic bust in Australia, the idea of a huge second-half surge is complete silliness.