At significant risk to your perceptions of me, I post this early on a Wednesday. Last week Adam posted an interview with Marion Nestle, who is a strong advocate for something that I can’t really figure out, but being charitable I presume it is adding warning labels for artificial food coloring on foods due to their effect on childhood hyperactivity. Her rationalizations are weak, and the evidence doesn’t seem to be on her side, but I was surprised (and delighted) to find this on my can of horrible high-alcohol malt liquor:

I have no idea where the inclination to add FD&C Blue #1 and Red #40 came from. I certainly didn’t care (not when there’s another label proclaiming 12% alcohol!). I would imagine that it has to be regulatory, since this isn’t even the class of product that do-gooders are worried about. On a related Adam Ozimek note regarding slippery slopes, an Iowa Congressman proposed legislation banning the mixing of alcohol with caffeinated beverages. I don’t think it got anywhere.
Update: Indeed, it looks as if this is due to regulation. So maybe not so much market reform leader as harbinger of regulatory burden. Apparently cochineal extract and carmine carry risks of severe allergic reaction, including anaphylaxis. I actually agree with this, as labels are fairly benign from a cost perspective, and widely illuminating if you happen to have such a condition. Much more rational than a ban based on dubious evidence.

3 comments
Comments feed for this article
Wednesday ~ April 13th, 2011 at 7:30 am
Adam Ozimek
That is a strange use of food colorings. I’m not sure if I’m understanding the labeling correctly though. If it’s FD&C blue #1 and FD&C red #40, then it’s not carmine, which is actually a natural flavoring. If it’s FD&C blue #1 and natural red #40, then it is carmine.
This coloring is a great example of the silliness of considering natural as somehow superior to artificial. Natural red #40 is more dangerous than artificial red #40, because of the possible effects you mention, and it’s made of boiled insects treated with an aluminum sulfate, so it’s more disgusting as well. But it is “natural”.
Wednesday ~ April 13th, 2011 at 8:50 am
IVV
Personally, I like the hubris involved with the distinction between “natural” and “artificial.” Anything plants or animals might produce is natural. But if humans make it, then it can’t be natural anymore, it must be artificial.
After all, humans can’t possibly be animals. Oh, no no no. They bend the laws of physics with their very existence.
Wednesday ~ April 13th, 2011 at 9:57 am
Latest Alcohol And Body Building Auctions : Body Building Blog | Free Fitness Tips & Body Building…
[...] Alcohol as Market Reform Leader « Modeled Behavior [...]